best used car bmw or mercedes

Best Used BMW & Mercedes: Top Picks for 2023

By Andrew Jackson
AD

When it comes to purchasing a used luxury car, two brands often top the list: BMW and Mercedes-Benz. Both offer a compelling mix of performance, craftsmanship, and prestige. But which is the better choice for you?

To help you navigate this decision, we've compiled a comprehensive guide comparing the best used BMW and Mercedes models, focusing on their strengths, reliability, and resale value.

Used BMW: Performance and Dynamics

BMWs are renowned for their sporty handling and exhilarating driving experience. Even in their used form, they maintain their driving prowess, making them an excellent choice for enthusiasts.

AD
4 Best BMW Models To Get As Your First Car (On A Budget)
4 Best BMW Models To Get As Your First Car (On A Budget)
Mercedes vs BMW vs Audi
Mercedes vs BMW vs Audi
Mercedes Benz Worth the Price
Mercedes Benz Worth the Price

BMW's 'Ultimate Driving Machine' philosophy is evident in models like the 3 Series and the M3. These compact luxury cars provide agile handling and impressive power. The 3 Series is also known for its practicality, offering ample space for passengers and luggage.

яма BMW reliability

BMWs, however, have a reputation for being less reliable than Mercedes. According to J.D. Power, BMW ranks below average in predicted reliability. Common issues include electrical gremlins and minor issues with the automatic transmission.

Photo Comparison: 2024 BMW 5 Series vs 2024 Mercedes E-Class
Photo Comparison: 2024 BMW 5 Series vs 2024 Mercedes E-Class
BWW vs MERCEDES benz
BWW vs MERCEDES benz
BMW vs Mercedes 2026: Which Luxury Car Brand Wins? Complete Comparison Guide
BMW vs Mercedes 2026: Which Luxury Car Brand Wins? Complete Comparison Guide

Maintaining a used BMW can be expensive, with high repair costs and steep parts prices. Nonetheless, regular maintenance and purchasing certified pre-owned (CPO) vehicles can mitigate these risks.

BMW Resale Value

BMWs hold their value impressively well. This is great news for used car buyers, as you'll get a car that's still high-quality even when it's several years old.

AD

Kelley Blue Book lists BMW as a top brand for retained value. For instance, a 3-year-old BMW 3 Series retains around 40% of its original value, compared to the average of about 30%.

two cars parked next to each other in a parking lot with trees in the background
two cars parked next to each other in a parking lot with trees in the background
What to choose BMW or MERCEDES 🫨?
What to choose BMW or MERCEDES 🫨?
Which Brand Of Car Is Better, Mercedes Or BMW?
Which Brand Of Car Is Better, Mercedes Or BMW?
BMW vs Benz Performance
BMW vs Benz Performance
three different cars parked side by side in a parking lot with the words bmw and mercedes
three different cars parked side by side in a parking lot with the words bmw and mercedes
BMW 330d vs Mercedes-Benz C 250 d — Which Is Better?
BMW 330d vs Mercedes-Benz C 250 d — Which Is Better?

Used Mercedes: Luxury and Comfort

Mercedes-Benz prioritizes comfort over outright performance. Their cars offer a smooth ride, high-end interiors, and cutting-edge technology features.

The E-Class and the S-Class are Mercedes' shining stars. These sedans provide unparalleled luxury, with spacious interiors and advanced safety features. The E-Class also offers a high-performing AMG variant for those seeking a sportier drive.

AD

Mercedes-Benz Reliability

Mercedes-Benz ranks higher than BMW in reliability ratings. J.D. Power gives Mercedes a 'Great' rating for predicted reliability, while BMW receives a 'Fair' rating.

a white car parked in front of a house
a white car parked in front of a house

Mercedes has also improved its reliability in recent years. Common issues like intricate, expensive repairs are less frequent in newer models. However, routine maintenance can still be pricey.

Mercedes-Benz Resale Value

While Mercedes-Benz vehicles maintain their value well, they generally do not hold onto their value as well as BMWs. However, high-end models like the S-Class still retain a significant portion of their original value.

AD

According to Kelley Blue Book, a 3-year-old Mercedes-Benz retains around 33% of its original value. This is slightly lower than BMW but still quite respectable.

In conclusion, the final decision depends on your priorities: sporty handling and better resale value in the case of BMW, or sumptuous luxury and better reliability with Mercedes-Benz. Ultimately, both brands offer exceptional used cars – you just need to pick the one that suits you best.

AD