bmw e34 vs e39

BMW E34 vs E39: Which Classic is Right for You?

By Ashley Taylor
AD

The BMW E34 and E39 are two iconic sedans from the German automaker, each with its own unique charm and performance characteristics. Produced between 1988 and 1996, the E34 was the fourth generation of the storied 3 Series, while the E39, introduced in 1998, was the fifth. Here, we compare these two automotive classics across key aspects.

Both the E34 and E39 are revered for their driving dynamics and timeless design, but significant differences exist under the hood and in their features. Let's delve into the world of these two BMWs and explore their similarities and differences.

Performance and Handling

The heart of the comparison lies in the performance each offers.

AD
an image of different cars that are in the same color and size, with each car on
an image of different cars that are in the same color and size, with each car on
two cars parked next to each other in front of a stone wall
two cars parked next to each other in front of a stone wall
two cars side by side with the same price
two cars side by side with the same price

The E34 was available with a range of inline-six engines, from the 2.0L producing 113 horsepower to the 4.0L 'M62' 'S38' engine in the 850CSi, which boasted a formidable 379 horsepower. This powerhouse was capable of 0-60 mph in just 5.7 seconds - impressive numbers for a car of its era.

Engine and Transmission

When it comes to engines, both E34 and E39 share the same inline-six design, but the E39 received updates that improved both power and efficiency. For instance, the base E39's 2.8L engine produced 192 horsepower, compared to the E34's 2.7L's 170 horsepower.

two bmws driving down the road in front of each other on a sunny day
two bmws driving down the road in front of each other on a sunny day
four different cars are shown with the same number on each car's front end
four different cars are shown with the same number on each car's front end
two cars parked side by side on the street
two cars parked side by side on the street

The E39 also introduced the innovative ZF 5HP19 5-speed automatic transmission, which became an industry standard due to its smooth and responsive shifting.

Chassis and Dynamics

Both models were lauded for their exceptional handling, but the E39 took it a step further with revised suspension geometry, better weight distribution, and wider tracks than the E34.

AD

The introduction of the optional Active Steering system on the E39 (now called Servotronic) provided additional agility at low speeds and improved stability at higher speeds, giving it a distinct advantage over the E34.

two cars side by side with one black and white photo, the other has an orange light
two cars side by side with one black and white photo, the other has an orange light
two cars parked next to each other in front of a sunset
two cars parked next to each other in front of a sunset
three pictures of the same car in different stages
three pictures of the same car in different stages
BMW 5 Series (E39)
BMW 5 Series (E39)
E34 BMW
E34 BMW
two different pictures of the same car, one is white and the other is black
two different pictures of the same car, one is white and the other is black

Design and Comfort

While both models sported BMW's iconic kidney grille and dual round headlights, design and comfort features set them apart.

Exterior and Interior Design

The E39's design, penned by Joji Nagashima, was cleaner and more mature than the E34's, reflecting the design trends of the late 90s. The E34, on the other hand, had a more angular, boxy look, reminiscent of the late 80s style.

AD

Inside, both cars offered luxurious and driver-focused interiors, but the E39 benefited from improved materials and build quality, giving it a more upscale feel compared to the E34.

three different cars with the same price on them
three different cars with the same price on them

Features and Technology

The E39 saw the introduction of several new technologies to the 3 Series, such as Dynamic Stability Control (DSC) and the first iteration of BMW's iDrive system. In contrast, the E34 was more analog, relying on traditional button-laden dashboards.

Both models offered a range of luxury features, but the E39's were more integrated and intuitive to use, providing a more seamless driving experience.

AD

In the realm of historic BMW sedans, choosing between the E34 and E39 comes down to personal preference. The E34 offers a raw, unadulterated driving experience, while the E39 delivers a more refined and technologically advanced one. Either way, both cars embody the classic BMW driving ethos: "Sheer driving pleasure."

AD