bmw e39 m5 vs e46 m3

BMW E39 M5 vs E46 M3: The Ultimate Showdown

By Daniel Lopez
AD

When it comes to high-performance sports sedans, the contenders are many, but none are as storied or revered as the BMW M5 and M3. The E39 M5 and E46 M3, produced between 1998 and 2000, remain iconized by automotive enthusiasts worldwide, each boasting unique qualities that set them apart. Let's delve into a comprehensive comparison of these two German powerhouses.

The E39 M5 and E46 M3 represent the pinnacle of what was possible in the late 90s and early 2000s in the high-performance sedan segment. But which of these two monstrous beasts reigns supreme? To answer this question, let's explore their performance, handling, design, and practicality.

Performance

The performance of both vehicles is nothing short of astounding for their era.

AD
an image of different cars that are in the same color and size, with each car on
an image of different cars that are in the same color and size, with each car on
three different cars parked side by side in front of each other, one red and one blue
three different cars parked side by side in front of each other, one red and one blue
two silver cars parked next to each other in front of a brick building with the words forever limities
two silver cars parked next to each other in front of a brick building with the words forever limities

Engine and Power

The E39 M5 is powered by a 4.9-liter S62 V8 engine that produces an impressive 394 horsepower and 390 lb-ft of torque. On the other hand, the E46 M3 uses a 3.2-liter S54 inline-six engine, outputting 333 horsepower and 269 lb-ft of torque.

Both engines employ aluminum construction for reduced weight and feature variable valve timing. But only the M5's V8 introduces four valves per cylinder for enhanced performance.

the bmw m5 evolution is shown in four different colors
the bmw m5 evolution is shown in four different colors
Car Videos, James Bond, Cars, Bmw, Train, Vehicles
Car Videos, James Bond, Cars, Bmw, Train, Vehicles
Buying Advice: E46 M3 or E39 BMW M5
Buying Advice: E46 M3 or E39 BMW M5

Speed and Acceleration

The E39 M5's superior power propels it from 0-60 mph in just 4.9 seconds, while the E46 M3 manages the same feat in 5.1 seconds. At the top end, the M5 crosses 100 mph in 12.5 seconds, leaving the M3 trailing behind at 13.8 seconds.

However, the M3 isn't left behind in corners. Its lighter weight and balanced chassis allow it to maintain momentum through curves, making it feel faster while having fun.

AD

Handling and Dynamics

Both vehicles handle exceptionally well, but each has its unique characteristics.

an image of bmw cars in different colors and sizes on a black background with sound waves
an image of bmw cars in different colors and sizes on a black background with sound waves
two black cars parked on the side of a road next to some bushes and trees
two black cars parked on the side of a road next to some bushes and trees
Bimmerleggera
Bimmerleggera
two cars side by side with one black and white photo, the other has an orange light
two cars side by side with one black and white photo, the other has an orange light
BMW e39 Inst: furdzz Inst: bmw_family_54
BMW e39 Inst: furdzz Inst: bmw_family_54
@BMV1444
@BMV1444

E39 M5: Grand Tourer

The E39 M5 is more of a grand tourer, focusing on long-distance comfort. It's regal and refined, stinting on rough roads with commendable poise. Its higher center of gravity and weight contributes to a slightly more substantial feel, yet the feedback from the steering wheel remains precise and positive.

E46 M3: Sporty Agility

The E46 M3 is more playful and agile, as expected from a dedicated sports sedan. With its lower stance and lighter curb weight, it hugs corners and dances through twists with a level of eagerness that surpasses the M5. Its steering is communicative and responsive, exuding a feeling of unfiltered connection to the road.

AD

Design and Style

Both vehicles exude a sense of aggressive beauty, yet their styles differ.

two cars parked next to each other in front of a building with pallets on the ground
two cars parked next to each other in front of a building with pallets on the ground

E39 M5: Sleek and Muscular

The E39 M5's design is sleek and muscular, drawing inspiration from the larger 7-Series. Its wide haunches, unmistakable dual exhaust pipes, and quad headlights exude sportiness wrapped in a luxurious shell. The interior is adorned with luxurious leather and cutting-edge technology for its time.

E46 M3: Compact and Athletic

The E46 M3, on the other hand, is more compact and athletic, taking after the E46 3-Series. Its design is characterized by distinctive shark-nose styling, aggressive dual kidney grilles, and quad exhaust tips. The interior is sporty, driver-focused, and practical, with excellent visibility and an intuitive layout.

AD

Ultimately, the choice between the E39 M5 and E46 M3 depends on your priorities. If you're after outright performance and long-distance comfort, the E39 M5 is your ride. But if cornering prowess and agility are high on your checklist, the E46 M3 is the one to drive off the lot. Both legends in their own right, they continue to inspire and excite enthusiasts the world over. So, which one will you choose for your garage?

AD