bmw x3 vs x4

BMW X3 vs X4: Which Compact Luxury SUV is Right for You?

By Matthew Thomas
AD

The BMW X3 and X4 have become popular choices in the luxury compact SUV segment, each catering to different preferences. To help you navigate these compelling offerings, let's delve into a comprehensive comparison, focusing on performance, design, tech, and practicality.

Before we dive into the details, let's clarify that the X4 slots below the X6 in BMW's range, while the X3 sits below the X5. This positioning reflects their capacity and features, as well as their unique appeal.

Design and Styling

The X3 and X4 share the same platform, but their styling sets them apart. The X3 is more traditionally SUV-like, with a higher ground clearance and a boxier design.

AD
two bmw suvs driving down the road
two bmw suvs driving down the road
BMW confirms X3 M and X4 M, here’s what we know so far
BMW confirms X3 M and X4 M, here’s what we know so far
Best BMW SUV comparison BMW X1 vs X2 vs X3 vs X4 vs X5 vs X6 vs X7 vs XM vs iX
Best BMW SUV comparison BMW X1 vs X2 vs X3 vs X4 vs X5 vs X6 vs X7 vs XM vs iX

Conversely, the X4 is sleeker, with a sloping roofline that gives it a more 'coupé-like' appearance. This design choice might compromise some rear headroom but adds a sportier aesthetic.

Interior Design

Both cabins are luxurious and driver-focused, hallmark of BMW's.execute inside. The dash is dominated by a large central display, with a leather-wrapped multifunction steering wheel and supportive seats.

We Drive the 503-HP BMW X3 M and X4 M: Are They Real-Deal M Cars? — MOTORTREND
We Drive the 503-HP BMW X3 M and X4 M: Are They Real-Deal M Cars? — MOTORTREND
FIRST DRIVE: 2020 BMW X4 M Competition and X3 M Competition
FIRST DRIVE: 2020 BMW X4 M Competition and X3 M Competition
BMW X3 And X4 M Could Get Over 500 HP Thanks To Competition Pack Offering
BMW X3 And X4 M Could Get Over 500 HP Thanks To Competition Pack Offering

However, the X4's roofline may slightly restrict headroom in the rear, reiterating the compromise in practicality for its sleeker design.

Exterior Design

The X3 presents a more traditional SUV feel, with a higher seating position and boxier, rugged look. The X4, on the other hand, offers a sportier, more dynamic design, with a lower roof and sleeker lines.

AD

Both vehicles feature BMW's signature kidney grille and full LED headlights, but the X4's sportier shape may catch more eyes.

2020 BMW X3 And X4 M40i Get Surprise Power Boost
2020 BMW X3 And X4 M40i Get Surprise Power Boost
two pictures of the same bmw suv
two pictures of the same bmw suv
Video: Autocar Reviews the BMW X3 M and X4 M
Video: Autocar Reviews the BMW X3 M and X4 M
BMW X3 vs BMW X4 - CarGurus
BMW X3 vs BMW X4 - CarGurus
BMW X4 vs. BMW X6 - What's the right choice for you?
BMW X4 vs. BMW X6 - What's the right choice for you?
Nine SUVs are now being built at the Spartanburg Plant
Nine SUVs are now being built at the Spartanburg Plant

Performance and Tech

Under the hood, both SUVs share similar engine options, focusing on performance and efficiency.

Both the X3 and X4 offer a range of turbocharged engines, starting with a 2.0-litre four-cylinder, up to a 300-horsepower, 3.0-litre inline-six in the M40i models. All-wheel drive comes standard, with an eight-speed automatic transmission.

AD

Driving Dynamics

The X3 and X4 both handle exceptionally for their class, thanks to BMW's xDrive all-wheel-drive system and a well-tuned suspension. The X4's lower stance and wider track deliver slightly sportier handling.

2014 vs 2018 BMW X4 Design Comparison
2014 vs 2018 BMW X4 Design Comparison

However, the X3's higher ride height and standard run-flat tires provide a slightly comfier ride and improved ground clearance.

Tech and Features

Both models come packed with tech features, starting with BMW's iDrive infotainment system, Apple CarPlay compatibility, and a comprehensive suite of driver-assistance systems.

AD

The X4 offers a head-up display as an optional extra, while the X3 offers a panoramic sunroof. Both vehicles feature a 10.25-inch touchscreen display and a high-quality sound system.

Practicality and Cargo Space

Practicality is where the X3 has the clear advantage. Its larger dimensions mean more cabin space and cargo capacity.

The X4's sloping roofline reduces headroom in the back and cuts into cargo space. However, both vehicles offer split-folding rear seats for increased cargo-carrying flexibility.

Cargo Space

The X3 offers more cargo space, with 28.7 cubic feet behind the second row, expanding to 62.7 cubic feet with the seats folded. The X4 provides less, with 20.9 cubic feet behind the second row, expanding to 50.5 cubic feet.

While the X4's cargo space may not be as generous as the X3's, it's still sufficient for most day-to-day use and weekend getaways.

Seating and Comfort

The X3's larger dimensions and higher roofline provide a more spacious interior, with more headroom for taller passengers. The X4's seating is more restrictive.

Both SUVs offer supportive, luxurious seating, with plenty of adjustment. However, the X3's more spacious interior may be more accommodating for families or taller passengers.

Ultimately, the choice between the BMW X3 and X4 depends on your priorities. If you prefer a sportier, lower-riding SUV, the X4 could be your ideal match. However, if practicality, cargo space, and seating comfort are your top concerns, the X3 will likely serve you better. Take a test drive of both to experience firsthand how each may fit your lifestyle.

AD