brooklyn style pizza vs new york style

Brooklyn vs New York: The Pizza Face-off

By Daniel Lewis
AD

Brooklyn and New York-style pizzas, both iconic to the city they originate from, have been a subject of debate among pizza lovers worldwide. Though both represent New York's culinary legacy, they differ significantly in crust, ingredients, and cooking method, each offering a unique taste experience.

Understanding the distinct features of these two pizza styles requires delving into their history and regional influences. Let's explore the fascinating world of Brooklyn style pizza vs New York style, their differences, and what makes each a classic in its own right.

Key Differences: Crust and Size

At the heart of the debate lies the pizza crust. New York-style pizza boasts a thin, foldable crust, typically larger in size, with a minimal amount of toppings maximizing cheese and sauce. This interpretation originates from Lombardi's, the first pizzeria in New York City, founded in 1905.

AD
Which Pizza Is More Authentic? Hand Tossed Vs Brooklyn Style
Which Pizza Is More Authentic? Hand Tossed Vs Brooklyn Style
New York Style Pizza vs. Chicago Pizza: What’s The Difference? - Brooklyn Craft Pizza
New York Style Pizza vs. Chicago Pizza: What’s The Difference? - Brooklyn Craft Pizza
22 Best Pizza in Brooklyn That You Don’t Want to Miss in 2024!
22 Best Pizza in Brooklyn That You Don’t Want to Miss in 2024!

In contrast, Brooklyn-style pizza features a slightly thicker crust, often with a noticeable chew, and smaller in size. This variation emerged from places like Grimaldi's beneath the Brooklyn Bridge, which opened in 1990. The Brooklyn style has a touch more cheekiness, allowing for a more diverse range of toppings.

Ingredients and Cooking Method

Además de la masa, la отца differs to Brooklyn and New York pizza styles, influences their unique textures and flavors. New York-style pizzas emphasize simple, traditional ingredients—fresh mozzarella, San Marzano tomatoes, and basil. They are cooked swiftly in a very hot oven, resulting in a crispy crust with slightly charred edges.

10 Fine Restaurants For You To Eat At in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn
10 Fine Restaurants For You To Eat At in Bed-Stuy, Brooklyn
a person holding up a slice of pizza in front of plates with cartoon drawings on them
a person holding up a slice of pizza in front of plates with cartoon drawings on them
New York Pizza Vs. Italian Pizza | Chef Joshua Weissman
New York Pizza Vs. Italian Pizza | Chef Joshua Weissman

Brooklyn-style pizzas sometimes incorporate more innovative or artisanal ingredients, reflecting the borough's diverse food culture. Their cooking method can vary as well, with some places using coal-fired ovens, imparting a subtle smokiness and deeper flavor.

Gas vs. Coal-Fired Ovens

New York-style pizzas are generally cooked in gas-fired ovens, creating a quick, intense heat which results in a well-done bottom crust and melted cheese on top. This method prioritizes speed and consistency, reflecting the city's fast-paced culture.

AD

Brooklyn-style pizzas may use either gas or coal-fired ovens. Coal-fired ovens provide a more variable heat, requiring skill and experience to regulate, but they can impart rich, distinct flavors. This method is more labor-intensive but revered for the deep, rustic taste it delivers.

6 Popular Pizza Styles You Should Know
6 Popular Pizza Styles You Should Know
What’s A Brooklyn Style Pizza?
What’s A Brooklyn Style Pizza?
Classic NYC Slices Shine At Brooklyn's Excellent New Norm’s Pizza
Classic NYC Slices Shine At Brooklyn's Excellent New Norm’s Pizza
Pizza from L’Industrie in Brooklyn 🍕
Pizza from L’Industrie in Brooklyn 🍕
Dominos Brooklyn Style Pizza 101: SECRETS REVEALED
Dominos Brooklyn Style Pizza 101: SECRETS REVEALED
12 Spots in Brooklyn for the BEST Pizza in New York City | Best of NYC | Food Guide | NYC Eats
12 Spots in Brooklyn for the BEST Pizza in New York City | Best of NYC | Food Guide | NYC Eats

Cheese, Sauce, and Toppings

Theys sauce variety in Brooklyn and New York pizzas isn't limited to crust and oven. New York-style pizzas are known for their tangy, slightly sweet marinara sauce, made primarily with canned tomatoes and herbs. The sauce-to-crust ratio is usually heavier, with a generous helping of whole-milk mozzarella cheese.

Conversely, Brooklyn-style pizzas can vary significantly across pizzerias. The sauce might be thinner, richer, or more proprietary. Toppings may span from classic to inventive, reflecting the borough's eclectic food scene. Cheese choices can range from traditional mozzarella to gourmet options, further diversifying the experience.

AD

Brooklyn-Style Innovation

Speaking of innovations, Brooklyn has become a hotbed for gourmet pizza. Pizzerias like L'Artista and Paulie Gee's offer unique combinations—from Korean BBQ to clams and bacon—proving that even traditional Neapolitan can evolve with cultural influences.

However, innovation doesn't always mean craziness. Many Brooklyn pizzerias pay homage to classic styles (like New York's foldable slices) while adding their unique twist. After all, New York was the first city in the U.S. to declare pizza its official food, so respect for tradition is paramount.

Ultimately, the Brooklyn vs. New York pizza debate isn't about which style is 'better'; it's about celebrating the diversity and richness of New York City's culinary heritage. Both styles have their merits, embodying different aspects of the city's character. So why not enjoy both—and let the debate continue?

AD
AD