BMW M5 GR Review: The Ultimate Track-Ready Sedan
The BMW M5 has long been a benchmark for high-performance sedans, and the latest iteration, the F90, continues this legacy with its stunning blend of raw power and everyday practicality. For automotive enthusiasts, the M5's "M" badge is a symbol of sporting prowess, THREE decades in the making. The recent G80 M5 model, introduced in 2017, raised the bar even further with an all-new, twin-turbo V8 powerplant that delivered unsettling performance in a discrete, four-door package.
However, the G80's vast capabilities often left many craving for a more visceral, engaging driving experience. Enter the M5 Competition Package, a sports-luxe upgrade that sharpened the M5's dynamics without compromising its everyday usability. The question on every petrolhead's mind, though, is: how does the M5 Competition Package fare against its predecessors, particularly the iconic E60 'gr' BMW M5? Let's dive in.
BMW M5 Through the Ages: The Evolution of a Sports Sedan
The BMW M5's saga began in 1984 with the E28, a car that forever changed the paradigm of what a high-performance sedan could be. Each successive generation built upon this foundation, culminating in the G80's nuovamente (newer) M xDrive all-wheel-drive system and 600+ horsepower outputs.
Yet, for many, the E60 M5, particularly the "gr" variant, remains an epitome of the M5's spirit. Unveiled in 2005, the E60 brought an upgrade in performance and technology, with its bad-girl reputation solidified by the 2009 'grue' (gr) version. So, how does the G80 Competition Package stack up against this legendary benchmark?
The معين (M-power) Question: Engine and Transmission
The E60 'gr' M5's S85 V10 engine, beside being High-revving symphony, delivered 507 hp and 383 lb-ft of torque - figures that seemed more Formula 1 than family car. By contrast, the G80 M5 Competition Package's S63 twin-turbo V8 produces 617 hp and 553 lb-ft. Despite the power jump, the new M5's engine lacks some the old V10's high-end charisma - a character deficit the Competition Package partially mitigates through its added aggression in Sport and Sport+ modes.
Both cars use a seven-speed dual-clutch transmission, but the G80's version offers quicker shifts and a smoother usability. The E60, however, earns brownie points for its classic manual option, which enhanced driving involvement and driver satisfaction.
Cornering Kings: Handling and Dynamics
The E60 'gr' M5's firm yet composed ride, precise steering, and incredible agility made it a cornering king. The G80, while capable, leans more towards grand tourer comfort. The Competition Package attempts to address this with recalibrated dampers, stiffer anti-roll bars, and a revised M Dynamic Mode, but it still falls short of the E60's outright handling prowess.
Both cars offer optional M xDrive all-wheel-drive systems, but the G80's M xDrive feels more like an electronic safety net, while the E60's xDrive (available from 2009) feels more integrated and palpable, thanks to its more rear-biased power split.
The Art of Discretion: Design and Practicality
The BMW M5 has always balanced outrageous performance with everyday usability. While the 'gr' E60 looked like a shark in a suit, the G80 M5 flies under the radar more effectively. The G80 also enjoys a more spacious interior with improved materials, yet the E60's driver-focused cockpit still feels more engaging.
The G80's 530-liter boot (trunk) is cavernous, but the E60's 465-liter space is more than adequate, especially when you consider the practicalities of the old-school saloon design.
Tech and Toy Box: Gadgets and Goodies
The G80 M5 is overflowing with modern tech - adaptive cruise, semi-autonomous driving, heads-up display, directional LED headlights, and acres of digital instrumentation. The E60, meanwhile, feels dated with its analog dials and basic navigation system, but some might argue that the lack of distraction technologies makes the driving experience more engaging.
Both cars offer a proliferation of driving modes and customizable settings, though the G80's array of options can sometimes feel overwhelming. The E60's simplicity, conversely, is refreshing but lacks the versatility of the newer model.
The BMW M5's journey has been one of relentless progress, ticking off power, performance, and technology milestones along the way. The G80 Competition Package, a modern marvel of engineering, rekindles the spirit of the iconic 'gr' E60 while building upon its foundation. However, it can never fully replicate the old girl's charm, character, and raw driving involvement. Ultimately, the choice between the two depends on whether you crave progress or long for nostalgia.