Subaru Ascent vs Toyota Highlander: 2023 SUV Showdown
When it comes to reliable and capable SUVs, two models often steal the spotlight: the 2022 Subaru Ascent and the 2022 Toyota Highlander. Both vehicles have garnered significant praise for their practicality, safety features, and family-friendly interiors. But which one is the better fit for your needs? Let's dive into a detailed comparison to explore how these two powerhouses stack up against each other.
First, let's consider the interior space and comfort each vehicle offers. Both the Ascent and Highlander provide ample space for passengers, but the Ascent takes the edge with its third-row seating. While both vehicles can accommodate eight passengers, the Ascent's third row offers more legroom and is suitable for adults on short trips.
Interior and Space
The Subaru Ascent boasts an impressive 153.5 cubic feet of passenger volume, compared to the Highlander's 141.0 cubic feet. This additional space can make a significant difference, especially for larger families or those who frequently carry extra passengers or cargo.
Moreover, the Ascent's interior is designed with versatility in mind. It features SUBARU's exclusive Boxer engine layout, providing more interior space without compromising handling or fuel efficiency. The Highlander, however, offers more cargo space behind the third row (16 cubic feet) than the Ascent (19.3 cubic feet), but the Ascent makes up for this with a larger cargo area with the third and second rows folded down (86.5 cubic feet compared to 84.3 cubic feet).
Cargo Space
When it comes to cargo space, both vehicles offer more than enough room for most people's needs. The Highlander, with its slightly larger cargo area behind the third row, might be the better choice for those prioritizing everyday utility. The Ascent, however, offers more cargo space when all seats are folded down, making it a stronger contender for those requiring occasional extra space for large items.
Interior Design and Comfort
Inside, both vehicles offer comfortable and practical interiors, but they have different design philosophies. The Highlander has a more conventional, truck-based SUV layout with a higher seating position, while the Ascent offers a lower, more car-like ride height, providing better visibility and handling. The Ascent's interior is also praised for its modern and sophisticated design, with higher-quality materials used throughout. The Highlander, on the other hand, has a more traditional, robust feel to it.
Performance and Handling
Under the hood, the Subaru Ascent is powered by a 2.4L turbocharged 4-cylinder engine producing 260 horsepower and 277 lb-ft of torque. The Toyota Highlander offers a choice between a 2.4L turbocharged 4-cylinder (Hybrid) and a 3.5L V6 engine (non-Hybrid). The Hybrid variant produces 243 horsepower, while the V6 generates 295 horsepower.
Despite the Highlander's V6 engine offering more horsepower on paper, the Ascent's turbocharged engine provides better acceleration and real-world performance. Both vehicles come standard with all-wheel drive, but the Ascent's Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive system is horizontally opposed, providing better balance and agility. The Highlander, while capable, has a more traditional truck-based suspension that results in a slightly firmer ride.
Fuel Efficiency
When it comes to fuel efficiency, the Subaru Ascent delivers an EPA-estimated 26 mpg combined (23 city/21 highway), while the Toyota Highlander Hybrid offers an impressive 36 mpg combined (34 city/30 highway). The non-Hybrid Highlander, however, achieves lower ratings with 22 mpg combined (21 city/27 highway). If fuel efficiency is your top priority, the Highlander Hybrid is undoubtedly the better choice.
Size and Dimensions
The Subaru Ascent is larger than the Toyota Highlander in nearly every dimension. The Ascent is 197.4 inches long, 78.3 inches wide, and 69.8 inches tall. The Highlander, in comparison, is 195.9 inches long, 78.5 inches wide, and 68.9 inches tall. Despite the Ascent's size, it offers better handling due to its lower ride height and more car-like suspension.
As consumers weigh the Subaru Ascent vs Toyota Highlander debate, it's essential to consider their individual needs. Although the Highlander is a strong contender with its spacious interior, advanced safety features, and impressive fuel efficiency, the Subaru Ascent's more car-like handling, extra interior space, and modern interior design give it an edge for many shoppers. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific requirements and preferences, but both vehicles represent excellent options in the midsize SUV segment.