the clarkson review bmw 3 series like being in a filing cabinet

The Clarkson Review: BMW 3 Series - Confined Comfort

By Michael Hernandez
AD

The BMW 3 Series has long been a benchmark in the compact executive car segment, admired for its sporty handling, luxurious interiors, and innovative technology. But according to legendary motoring journalist Jeremy Clarkson, driving the latest 3 Series is akin to "being in a filing cabinet." Now, that's not the typical metaphor you'd expect from a car review, so let's delve into Clarkson's unique perspective and explore what makes the reviewed 3 Series stand out, both positively and negatively.

Jeremy Clarkson's filing cabinet comparison might seem harsh, but it's his way of highlighting the 3 Series' evolutionary design and familiar interior. The 3 Series has always been about subtlety and refinement, so it's no surprise Clarkson likens it to an organized and functional office staple. However, there's much more to explore in the design, technology, and performance fronts that set the 3 Series apart.

Design: Evolution, Not Revolution

The 3 Series' design is a study in evolution, with familiar lines and forms carrying over from its predecessors. It's a conservative approach that ensures consistency in BMW's most important model, but it also means the 3 Series isn't CMS0He0qxI as striking or groundbreaking as some of its competitors.

AD
a man standing next to a white car in front of a building
a man standing next to a white car in front of a building
Our 10 Favorite Milestones In The History Of The BMW 3 Series - Petrolicious
Our 10 Favorite Milestones In The History Of The BMW 3 Series - Petrolicious
Here’s Why I’ll Die Before I Buy a BMW
Here’s Why I’ll Die Before I Buy a BMW

A closer look, however, reveals refined details like the kidney grille's larger size, slimmer headlights with LED lighting, and a more muscular stance thanks to wider luggage compartment lid and rear bumper. Inside, the cabin is typical BMW - clean, elegant, and loaded with high-quality materials. Yet, as Clarkson points out, it feels like a familiar space, perhaps even reminiscent of a well-organized office.

Interior Technology: Tech-Packed and Convenient

Despite the filing cabinet comparison, the 3 Series' interior is packed with cutting-edge technology. The new, larger 12.3-inch digital instrument cluster and the 10.25-inch central infotainment screen offer crisp graphics and smooth operation. BMW's latest iDrive system offers intuitive control, and the supportive seats ensure long-term comfort.

WORLD PREMIERE: BMW 3 Series Sedan Facelift — Sharp Dressed Sedan
WORLD PREMIERE: BMW 3 Series Sedan Facelift — Sharp Dressed Sedan
BMW 3 Series M Sport 🏁
BMW 3 Series M Sport 🏁
Evolution of the Legendary BMW 3 Series - Infographic Portal
Evolution of the Legendary BMW 3 Series - Infographic Portal

'illJABSOqBQ features like wireless charging, a head-up display, and bi-directional wireless device charging add convenience and premium feel. While the technology is impressive, some critics argue that the interface is not as intuitive as some rivals, perhaps contributing to Clarkson's filing cabinet analogy.

Driving Experience: Sporty, Composed, and Safe

The 3 Series offers a range of powertrains, from the eco-friendly 330e plug-in hybrid to the scorching M340i performance variant. Yet, it's the 330d diesel model Clarkson tested, known for its balance of performance and efficiency. With 265 horsepower and impressive torque, the 330d offers muscular acceleration and agile handling.

AD

Around twists and turns, the 3 Series feels light and responsive, showcasing BMW's traditional driving dynamics. The eight-speed automatic transmission is smooth and responsive, and the optional adaptive M suspension provides a comfortable yet engaging ride. Safety is another strong suit, with the 3 Series earning top ratings from both Euro NCAP and the IIHS.

two pictures of the same car in different angles, one is black and the other has gold rims
two pictures of the same car in different angles, one is black and the other has gold rims
BMW😫
BMW😫
BMW 3-Series Touring (2026) Long Term Test
BMW 3-Series Touring (2026) Long Term Test
bmw 3 series
bmw 3 series
New BMW 3 Series 2019 review - pictures | Auto Express
New BMW 3 Series 2019 review - pictures | Auto Express
"BMW 3 Series – Where luxury meets performance with timeless style and power."
"BMW 3 Series – Where luxury meets performance with timeless style and power."

Practicality and Comfort

The 3 Series is a practical everyday car, with a generous boot (420 liters), supportive seats, and ample legroom in the rear. Build quality is exemplary, with solid-feeling switchgear and high-quality materials throughout. However, Clarkson highlights that the rear seats and boot might feel slightly less spacious than in some competitors, contributing to his filing cabinet comparison.

On the comfort front, the 3 Series impresses with its smooth ride, noise insulation, and a range of comfort features. Yet, some might find the optional active suspension and steering settings too clinical, preferring a more natural, less filtered feel.

AD

Fuel Efficiency and Running Costs

Depending on the chosen powertrain, the 3 Series can offer impressive fuel efficiency. The 330d diesel model Clarkson tested delivers up to 57.3 mpg (combined cycle), while the 330e plug-in hybrid can achieve up to 166 MPGe and has an electric range of up to 37 miles. Regular maintenance costs are reasonable, and BMW's residuals are among the best in the segment.

bmw 3 series
bmw 3 series

Nevertheless, depreciation and insurance costs can be high, which might offset the fuel savings for some. Plus, opting for high-end trims and options can significantly increase the initial cost, making the 3 Series more expensive than some rivals.

The BMW 3 Series is a remarkable car, offering an engaging driving experience, luxurious interiors, and innovative technology. Jeremy Clarkson's filing cabinet comparison might seem derogatory, but it underscores the 3 Series' familiar, evolved design and functional interior. Ultimately, the 3 Series is a well-rounded, premium compact executive car that sets the standard in its segment. So, if you appreciate understated elegance, traditional driving dynamics, and cutting-edge tech, the BMW 3 Series is worth considering - even if it does remind Clarkson of an office staple.

AD
AD