ugliest car from bmw

BMW's Ugliest Car: Which Takes the Cake?

By Nicole Williams
AD

The influenza of automobile aesthetics is a matter of profound subjectivity, multifariously dictated by personal preferences and cultural zeitgeists. However, one model from BMW's repertoire has consistently drawn the ire of critics and enthusiasts alike for its polarizing design: the 1975 BMW 5 Series, fondly (or infamously) known as the 'D breakpoint'.

Born into an era of radical automotive design, the E12/E28 5 Series is often crowned the 'ugliest BMW' by connoisseurs and historians. But what exactly equips this vintage sedan with such notoriety? Let's indulge in an origin story and discuss the criticisms that have made the 'ugliest car from BMW' an infamous name in automotive lore.

The Ugly Duckling: 1975 BMW 5 Series

The 1975 5 Series, or E12, was an ambitious venture by BMW, attempting to fill the void left by the popular 2002. It was a larger, more luxurious brother, with streamlined performance and comfort at its core. Yet, while the car below the surface was remarkable, its exterior design stirred up a barrage of disparaging remarks.

AD
BMW i3 REX
BMW i3 REX
40 Years of Electric BMWs You Can't Buy
40 Years of Electric BMWs You Can't Buy
the bmw concept car is being displayed at an auto show
the bmw concept car is being displayed at an auto show

parking lot filled with BMWs, the 5 Series stood out like a sore thumb, earning it the dubious distinction of the 'ugliest car from BMW'.

The Design: A Sense of Disjointedness

The 5 Series' countenance was dominated by an elongated, upright grille, flanked by large, round headlights. Its cheeks were high and width proportionately narrow, giving it an elongated, frog-like appearance. The overall effect was one of disproportion, with critics likening it to a cross between a flatiron and a bloated toad.

a silver car parked on top of a parking lot
a silver car parked on top of a parking lot
True Story; The World’s Ugliest BMW X6 Will Cost You $100,000 | Carscoops
True Story; The World’s Ugliest BMW X6 Will Cost You $100,000 | Carscoops
a car that has been decorated with blood and teeth
a car that has been decorated with blood and teeth

But the 5 Series wasn't just a victim of its front fascia. The sedan's posteriors were equally contentious, with some describing it as a 'bustle-back' design, reminiscent of late 19th-century horse-drawn carriages. The car's lines were indeed untraditional, resulting in an unappealing appearance that divided opinion even among BMW enthusiasts.

The Era: A Tale of Two Poles

The E12's launch in the mid-1970s coincided with an era of experimentation in car design. Some hits, many misses, and the 5 Series was arguably among the biggest. Its contemporary, the Audi 50, was similarly criticized for its unusual aesthetics, reflecting the tumultuous design trends of the time.

AD

On the flip side, the 1970s were also a decade of great innovation and ingenuity. Among its peers, the 5 Series' design was a stark contrast to the timeless modernity of the 3 Series or the race-car looks of the M1. Consequently, amidst this aesthetic polar bear market, the 5 Series' peculiarity stood out even more.

a white truck with big tires parked on the grass in front of a fenced yard
a white truck with big tires parked on the grass in front of a fenced yard
an old car is parked on the side of the road
an old car is parked on the side of the road
Car Wallpapers, Cool Cars, Cars, Cars Trucks, Bmw
Car Wallpapers, Cool Cars, Cars, Cars Trucks, Bmw
a black car parked on the side of a road next to a fence and grass
a black car parked on the side of a road next to a fence and grass
a black car with an evil face on it's hood
a black car with an evil face on it's hood
a black car with an evil face painted on it's front grill and mouth
a black car with an evil face painted on it's front grill and mouth

The Impact: Cursed or Blessed?

The E12 and its successor, the E28, which persisted until 1988, eventually earned a cult following. Despite its questionable aesthetics, the 5 Series provided rivals such as the Mercedes-Benz W123 and Jaguar XJ6 with formidable competition, significantly bolstering BMW's reputation and market share.

Its design inheritors, like the E34 (1988-1996), further refined the 5 Series formula, separating aesthetics from core performance. Today, the 'ugly duckling' of yesteryears is considered an integral part of BMW's heritage, embodying the brand's spirit of fearless innovation. Its legacy, therefore, is a paradoxical testament to the power of controversial design.

AD

Controversy: Friend or Foe?

In the realm of automobile aesthetics, controversy can either spell death for a model or bestow upon it an indomitable legacy. The 1975 BMW 5 Series is a prime example of the latter. Far from being merely 'ugly', the 'dreadful' design choices of the E12 have guaranteed its place in automotive infamy.

a silver bmw z4 convertible parked on the side of the road next to the ocean
a silver bmw z4 convertible parked on the side of the road next to the ocean

Its impact on the motoring world transcends beyond mere aesthetics. It spurred debates about automotive design, challenged conventions, and catapulted BMW into the realm of competitive luxury sedans. Eventually, the 5 Series' burden of ugliness transformed into an asset, branding it as the most controversial car from BMW.

The 1975 BMW 5 Series stands as a living testament to the adage 'beauty is in the eye of the beholder'. Its legacy continues to fuel passionate debates among car enthusiasts and inaugrates a fascinating narrative into BMW's rich history. Despite its controversial aesthetic, the 'ugliest car from BMW' ignites in us an appreciation for the bold, unafraid designs that challenge our perception of vehicle beauty. Explore BMW's diverse fleet today and discover the unique aesthetics that make each one a Foray into the Rich Tapestry of Automotive Design.

AD
AD